Selective Environmental Concern
I see people touting the 'win' for the planet in the form of the 'greening' caused by elevated CO₂ levels. I don't know if 'irony' or 'hypocrisy' are the right words to describe this fossil fuel industry talking point deployed by people who never expressed concern about the browning of the Earth caused by overgrazing, or the loss of biodiversity caused by deforestation to make way for pasture and animal feed crops. Claude: You've identified something real and rhetorically important here. The word you might be reaching for is motivated reasoning — or more precisely, selective concern . The people deploying the "CO₂ greening" talking point aren't making a principled ecological argument; they're making a momentary rhetorical move. Their sudden enthusiasm for plant life conveniently materializes only when it serves to minimize concern about emissions, and evaporates entirely when the topic is habitat destruction, monoculture, or de...