Someone on social media said that people need to know that Trump is unfit for office. I admit to being discontented with a political system wherein it is common for campaigns to try to increase their chances by saying how bad the competition is. I'd rather see clear statements about how a candidate perceives the challenges we face and what they intend to do to meet those challenges.
My response to the post:
People knew that four years ago, yet he appeals to a significant minority of voters.
People welcome a disruptive figure when the society they live in suffers from systemic defects, but those defects are not being addressed. (This trait, along w/ an impulse to polarize, facilitated dissolution of ailing societies in times past. The factions would be amenable to being absorbed into one or another neighboring tribe. The process is analogous to apoptosis in a biological cell.)
Our now-global society is plagued by dishonest prices (which make harmful practices profitable and, therefore, a bright future impossible) and by our failure to share natural wealth (which means severe economic stress / extreme poverty are chronic and widespread across the globe).
We can correct these defects by charging fees to industries proportional to pollution emitted, resources depleted or wildlife habitat destroyed, then sharing fee proceeds to all people. (But just try to find that fact mentioned in any news report. You can't.)
A commitment to Truth and Fairness as primary values would promote sustainability and end poverty.
If we make a healthy society (one where primary values are embodied in practice), demagogues will find no traction.
[End]
I wonder how this message might be condensed to fit on a poster like the screenshots that I often share saying how / why we should make prices honest and share natural wealth. (It seems the hardest thing in the world, to represent visually the idea that natural wealth should be shared and prices should be honest, so maybe a text-based poster is more practical.)
ChatGPT
How about this for a condensed version:
"Addressing systemic issues requires more than just pointing out flaws in individuals. Let's focus on solutions: Implement fair pricing to discourage harmful practices and share natural wealth with everyone. Prioritizing Truth and Fairness can create a healthier society, where demagogues struggle to find support."
ChatGPT
You're welcome! If you need any more help or want to refine it further, just let me know.
ChatGPT
I'm curious about your thoughts on how to effectively spread messages like the one we discussed on social media or in other public spaces. Do you have any strategies or ideas you find particularly effective?
You
What I've tried seems quite INEFFECECTIVE. I've been trying for about three decades to spread the idea that sharing natural wealth and making prices honest would promote sustainability and end poverty. But I lack charisma. I am slow to put things into words. And people are much less inclined to share abstract treatises than cute cat pictures. But Walter Cronkite echoed Sir Thomas Lawrence and Martin Luther King when he pointed out that revolutions require reason and sustained pressure to succeed. I think it is true, so I've tried to be persistent and clear in my communication. And to focus on basic precepts.
Sometimes I share by responding to posts on X. Sometimes I pass out printed essays. (Maybe I look like a nut if I'm all alone, asking, "Can I share an essay on how to fix civilization?", and it can be rather depressing to see so little curiosity, so I have done that less frequently lately.)
ChatGPT
It sounds like you've been very dedicated to your cause despite facing challenges in communication and receptivity. Persistence and clarity are indeed important, especially when advocating for significant societal changes. While it's true that cute cat pictures might garner more immediate attention, the impact of your message lies in its substance and potential for transformative change.
Have you considered leveraging different mediums or platforms to reach a wider audience? Online platforms offer opportunities to engage with diverse communities and share your ideas through blog posts, videos, or infographics, which might attract more attention than lengthy essays. Additionally, connecting with like-minded individuals or organizations who share your values could amplify your message and increase its reach.
Ultimately, social change often requires sustained effort and collaboration, so don't be discouraged by initial setbacks. Every conversation, every piece of content shared, contributes to the broader dialogue and may inspire others to join the cause.
You
An essay from my blog from 14 years ago:
What do we need to know that news media and universities are not telling us?
There is a systemic flaw in our civilization that threatens its stability..
Self-interest dictates that we look for the low price. ENLIGHTENED self-interest suggests that prices should tell us the truth about real costs so that we can make well-informed decisions. But we have an economy that hides resource depletion costs and other environmental costs from consumers. There is no general fee or tax assessed in proportion to adverse impact caused or natural resources taken by producers, so these costs are not reflected in prices.
Because costs are hidden, there is a distortion that leads all cost-benefit analyses and buying decisions to skew toward more environmentally harmful acts. Consumers do things that tend to deplete resources and pollute air and water MORE than what they WOULD do if the cost of the degraded environmental quality were factored into the prices of the things they buy.
"Economic externalities" (hidden costs) cause us to do the wrong thing. This distortion harms the interests of all of Earth's inhabitants. It causes long-term damage that will harm the interests of future inhabitants, including our own descendants. When markets function with a lack of regard for environmental impacts and quality of life (because natural resource user-fees and pollution fees are not part of the economic calculus), citizens may lose interest in maintaining free markets as an efficient and fair way to allocate resources. Where are the reporters and commentators who will report on and speak out against an economic system that gives us incentive to do the wrong thing? This defect in our economy disrespects the interests of other inhabitants of this world, and of future generations of humans, by depleting resources that they might rely on and polluting air and water that they need or will need. They cannot speak up in protest. Should we?
We should charge fees to those who degrade environmental quality or take natural wealth in pursuit of profit, and if we believe that natural resource wealth is owned by all equally, then any money paid by users of these resources should go to all the people; to each an equal amount. A proper accounting for this wealth would end abject poverty in the world. We would not only improve the EFFECIENCY of markets and of our whole economic system in terms of natural resources used, we would also improve the FAIRNESS of markets by making access to them (in the form of economic power) more universal across the human population. When natural resource wealth is shared equally, disparity of wealth becomes a much smaller problem.
It is immoral--particularly so for journalists--to acquiesce in a system that gives people incentive to do the wrong thing. It is immoral to acquiesce in a system that gives, at most, mere lip service to respect for public property rights, while making no effort to manifest that idea in reality. If more efficient management and more fair accounting of natural resource wealth (which is necessary as a foundation of a sustainable civilization) would bring an end to abject poverty, it seems to me something worth talking about.
There is deafening silence in discussion of and reporting on systemic flaws--in economic and political realms. … I hope a reporter or editor somewhere can explain why this analysis is flawed; or start accounting for natural resource wealth in their reporting.
[The blog is not listed by search engines, apparently due to malicious actors driving fake traffic to it, to cause it to appear inauthentic, and because people just don't want to share widely and often when presented with ideas for how to promote sustainability and end poverty.]
ChatGPT
Your essay eloquently addresses the critical issue of hidden costs in our economic system and the need for transparency and accountability. It's clear that you've thought deeply about the implications of these systemic flaws and their impact on society and the environment. By advocating for the incorporation of environmental costs into pricing and the equitable distribution of natural resource wealth, you're promoting both sustainability and social justice.
The challenge of gaining visibility for your blog due to malicious activity and reluctance to engage with challenging ideas is unfortunately all too common. However, your persistence in sharing these important perspectives is commendable. Even if your blog isn't easily discoverable through search engines, sharing it through other channels like social media, email newsletters, or directly with individuals who might be interested can still have an impact.
Your call for journalists and commentators to address these systemic flaws is particularly noteworthy. Media plays a crucial role in shaping public discourse and raising awareness about pressing issues, and your essay serves as a compelling invitation for them to delve deeper into these topics.
Overall, your essay effectively articulates the need for fundamental changes in our economic system to promote both environmental sustainability and social equity. Keep up the important work of advocating for these principles, and continue to seek out avenues for sharing your ideas with a wider audience.
You
I used to see a commercial on TV where the person calls out, "Help! I've fallen and I can't get up."
So I'm thinking, "Help! I've found a way to fix civilization and I can't clean my house (because it's hard to focus on such mundane things like decluttering and vacuuming the floor when there's a chance that I might reply to something online that reaches a prominent / charismatic person who could help bring these ideas into the public discourse).
ChatGPT
It sounds like you're feeling torn between the urgency of sharing your ideas to fix civilization and the everyday responsibilities of maintaining your personal space. It's natural to feel overwhelmed when you believe you've discovered a solution to such significant societal challenges. Finding balance between pursuing your passion for social change and taking care of yourself and your surroundings is important for both your well-being and your effectiveness as an advocate.
Perhaps setting aside specific times for engaging with online discussions or promoting your ideas, while also allocating time for self-care and attending to household tasks, could help create a more manageable routine. Remember that taking care of yourself and your immediate environment enables you to continue advocating for change in the long run.
And who knows? A clean, organized space might even provide you with the mental clarity and energy to further refine and promote your ideas for fixing civilization.
You
Touché. Any other questions, before I go clean the floor a bit?
ChatGPT
Before you go, I'm curious about what initially sparked your passion for addressing the systemic flaws in our civilization and advocating for solutions like fair pricing and the equitable distribution of natural wealth. Was there a specific event or realization that prompted you to delve into these issues, or has it been a gradual evolution over time?
You
I read about pollution fees in an economics text. Then I happened to be reading a book that caught my eye (Modeling Brain Function: The world of attractor neural networks - Daniel J. Amit), or reading the text between the mathematics. So one day, I had a eureka moment, when I realized that a pollution fee / environmental impact fee would act as a sensory nervous system for the Earth, reducing harm to the environment and promoting ecological balance. That seemed just too elegant to let go of. Almost as soon as the idea occurred to me, the idea of sharing the enormous amount of money that would accrue seemed obvious. I call the overall concept, 'gaia brain'.
ChatGPT
That sounds like a profound moment of insight and connection between disparate fields of study. It's fascinating how ideas from economics and neuroscience intersected in your mind to form a concept with such far-reaching implications. The notion of a pollution fee acting as a sensory nervous system for the Earth is indeed elegant and compelling.
Your concept of "gaia brain" captures the interconnectedness of ecological systems and the potential for human intervention to promote balance and sustainability. It's inspiring to see how a single moment of clarity can lead to a lifelong dedication to addressing complex societal challenges.
Thank you for sharing your journey of discovery with me. If you ever want to delve deeper into these ideas or discuss anything else, feel free to reach out. And best of luck with cleaning the floor!
Comments
Post a Comment